Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


And abolishing ICE! Why should states be forced to host armies they don't agree with?


Strange that suddenly they don’t seem to like this concept so much anymore :)

“I support the right of $state to ban $thing”

Wait, not like that!


States don't have "rights", people do. I don't support any state's power to take away any human's rights. And bootlickers who do shouldn't have the chance to act out their fascistic fantasies


It's reasonable to believe that a blanket ban on data centers constitutes a regulatory taking, and therefore run afoul of people's property rights. A data center doesn't pose some unreasonable risk to the public interest to justify this degree of action.


This is far from a blanket ban.


It’s a ban on any DC over 20 megawatts, regardless of site or situation - that’s a blanket ban because there’s no exceptions or justifications for the ban to apply to every large DC, regardless of location.

From what I can tell, case law on takings via this kind of regulation is “case by case”, without a clear test for when it crosses over the line into an unreasonable imposition on property rights.


It's a pause. And not a particularly long one either.

Maine is saying "we don't have the legal infrastructure to make sure we can build these out in a way that protects the environment and our residents so let's put a pause on building while we build up that framework"


> I don't support any state's power to take away any human's rights.

Absolutely agreed. Which is why I'm firmly against Maine's proposal here


Maine is saying "hey give us until 2027 to research this and provide a good regulatory framework for massive data centers that don't impede on human rights to clean water and air". The moratorium expires after 2027.

What human right is being violated here?

Would you also say the requirement to get a driver's license is a violation of a human right?


"We need to put a """temporary""" moratorium to infringe on your right to $thing until we figure out what the hell is going on"

No thanks


Some people are addicted to the taste of boots. In most of the US, small cities are being bullied around by huge tech firms that have taken over their political infrastructure and bought out their politicians. The people of Maine are sticking up to bid-rigging, bribery, and political collusion. More power to them

They're not even the first. Kentucky is facing fallout from uncovered collusion between local officials and developers (Western Hospitality Partners) to advance a data center project and they've also had to place a moratorium.


> In most of the US, small cities are being bullied around by huge tech firms that have taken over their political infrastructure and bought out their politicians.

You have evidence for this claim?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: